Oak branch selection for initial styling

Hi all, I’m working on the initial styling for an oak and trying to figure out my next move for setting the initial structure on the primary trunk on the left. This will likely be the front (bottom picture) and I zoomed in on the 4 large branches that are the biggest problem area. I would love any input or considerations regarding what to leave or take off

I cut the trunks back a bit more to help better visualize the issue. I know it’s out of season but based on a few factors I was willing to roll the dice

Nice oak!

I would remove the 2 branches with lines to the left. The higher one is dependent on whether you can develop the branch circled on the right and wire the other branch on the right. That being said, that upper left branch doesn’t need to be removed as much as that lower one

1 Like

Thanks for the input! I think I agree the lowest should go. This might be me being a beginner and following doctrine, but why leave opposing branches? Would you not be concerned with inverse taper? I took a picture from another angle and marked the same branches as you did

That clears things up more. I would just take the lower branch off for now. That will significantly slow the swelling in that area. Keep the branch mid trunk above those, wire it for some movement before it gets any thicker. Same with that lower right branch. The thing with oaks for me, I want to create a natural looking tree and oaks often times have branches like that. I don’t find them to become hideously swollen with inverse taper. You might even consider cutting that left branch back to the junction to give movement to an otherwise immovable thicker branch. Blue lines are my revised idea with the new information. Also that wound you’ve pasted over, you can consider making it a shallow hollow and as time passes it will weather and age making the tree look older.

1 Like

Thanks for the additional input. I’ll definitely remove that lower branch and wire the other two when I get a chance.

I’ll keep trying to chase buds back down the branches to add movement and ramification as well, I don’t think any of them will remain as long as they are now. I couldn’t find a ton of information on the behavior of this oak so I cut back to viable buds and left on length to be safe.

interesting idea on a hollow, I’ll keep that in mind as the tree develops and recovers from this initial chop and the upcoming repot

1 Like

Do you know the species?

In native range for my coastal oaks, I can 95% of the time cut back to a dormant bud site in spring before the push of growth, and get a branch to push from it, but the tree has to be strong and ready to start moving or already moving resources

It was listed as a quercus ilex at the nursery. I’ve had good success with dormant buds when I cut back to the last viable bud on each branch. My hope is to get the older wood to back bud so I can remove the long spindly branches and push the ramification tighter to the trunk. I just wasn’t confident enough to cut to points with no existing buds

I’m also in SoCal and my scrub and cork oaks bud aggressively!

1 Like